Planning For Graduate SchoolPrepared byDr. Carlos Goldberg, Ph.D. Department of Psychology Indiana University-Purdue University at Indianapolis The purpose of this paper is to guide Psychology Majors who are planning to apply to Graduate School. This paper is essentially a summary of Getting In published by the American Psychological Association (APA, 1993). Getting In provides a realistic picture of the difficulties in getting accepted to a graduate program, but you should not be discouraged from applying to Graduate School, provided you have the necessary qualifications. For example, the average applicant-to-opening ratios are 25-to-1 or higher, but you will increase your chances of being accepted to a program if you follow the steps outlined in this paper.
Step 1: Is Graduate School Right for You?Needless to say, this is the first question you need to answer. Graduate School is not for everyone, and you may not have the necessary qualifications to be accepted.There are a number of reasons for pursuing an M.A. or Ph.D. degree in Psychology. You will need a Ph.D. degree to teach at the college level, lead major research in a university or business setting, or practice psychotherapy. You will need an M.A. degree for many jobs in government and industry, and a master's degree in psychology is often considered ideal. Other common reasons for pursuing a graduate degree are a deep interest in psychology, an aspiration to make a contribution to the field, and a strong wish to improve the quality of life for individuals and society. In addition to the reasons for pursuing an advanced degree, you should be aware that graduate work is difficult and very demanding. The average course load ranges from 9 to 14 credits per semester, and you are expected to do a great deal of reading and thinking on your own. You will also be required to spend a good deal of time in planning and conducting research. In general, the largest share of your life will be devoted to graduate work, and to your professional career as well. It takes 2 to 4 years to obtain an M.A. degree, and 4 to 7 years to obtain a Ph.D. degree. Your chances for the successful completion of the degree requirements will depend on how hard- working, self-motivated, interested in the field, and how scientifically oriented you are.
The minimum GRE score required for a Ph.D. program is 550 in each of the subtests: Verbal, Quantitative, Analytical, and Psychology. However, not all programs use the Analytical Score and the Psychology Score in evaluating applicants. For an M.A. program the minimum GRE score is 500 in each of the subtests. The above figures for GPA and GRE scores are averages, and many programs set higher minimums for these criteria. Graduate Programs may also use additional selection criteria besides the ones listed above, such as quality of course work, interviews, research experience, psychology-related work experience, clinically-related public service, and extracurricular activities.
Step 2: Area of Concentration and Type of DegreeKnowledge of the different careers in psychology and the necessary degrees is essential to making choices about your graduate plans. You need to think about:
Three Models of Training and Practice in Psychology
Training in the research scientist model focuses on supplying students with the knowledge and tools necessary for scientific investigation. Typically, students are given rigorous training in research methods, and they are required to complete coursework in the core areas of psychology, such as perception, sensation, learning, memory, personality, motivation, quantitative, developmental, physiological, and social psychology. In addition to courses in the core areas, students are expected to take courses in their areas of concentration and to begin doing research in those areas as soon as possible. According to a 1991 survey, 8% of new Ph.Ds in psychology were employed in careers focusing almost exclusively on research. About 31% of these researchers were employed in universities, and about 52% were employed in business and government settings (Kohout and Wicherski, 1993). Of course, among the new graduates, a much larger percentage than 8% were involved in research as part of their professional lives.
Programs following this model require more coursework in applied and clinical subjects, and more experience in internships and practica in clinical and applied settings. Although the scientist-practitioner model is often used in clinical psychology, it is also prevalent in other areas, such as counseling, school, and industrial/organizational psychology. Scientist-practitioner training is characterized by core courses in both basic and applied psychology, supervision during extensive clinical or applied experience, research consumption, and an emphasis on the application of the scientific skills that are fundamental to the practice of psychology. For example, in treating a client, the scientist-practitioner would use scientific skills such as generating hypotheses about the causes of the problem, operationalizing variables that are pertinent to treatment, using interventions that have a scientific basis, testing hypotheses, and empirically evaluating the results of interventions.
Some professional schools are university-based and some are freestanding. University-based schools are considered by some as the optimal setting for professional programs. Some of these programs are separate schools within a university, and university-based schools have the advantages of access to facilities such as libraries, counseling centers, and they have closer contact with other disciplines within the university. Some PsyD programs are based in university psychology departments which may also grant research-oriented PhDs. Freestanding professional schools are usually private institutions that are autonomous from both psychology departments and universities, and they are controversial. In 1987, The National Conference on Graduate Education recommended that after 1995 all freestanding schools be university-affiliated to be accredited by the APA. Common criticisms of freestanding schools are as follows: Library facilities may be inadequate; programs may be too isolated from related disciplines; some rely too heavily on tuition for funding; in many, faculty members are practitioners and teach only part-time; and it is more difficult to assess the quality of freestanding schools than that of university-based schools. Of course, these criticisms may apply to only some freestanding schools. The number of students opting for a PsyD degree through professional programs appear to be growing. According to a 1991 survey, 500 PsyD degrees were granted, which was about 15% of all psychology doctoral degrees granted that year. The employment rate for PsyD graduates is also encouraging - 77% of 1991 PsyD graduates in clinical psychology reported full-time employment as compared to 70% for PhD clinical graduates (Kohout and Wicherski, 1993).
The PhD degree is usually granted by university-based psychology departments that train in the research or scientist-practitioner models, although some professional schools also award the PhD degree. The PsyD degree is usually granted by a university-based or freestanding professional school of psychology that trains with the professional model. The EdD degree is granted by a university-based education department, as opposed to a psychology department, which usually trains in the research or scientist-practitioner models.
There is very little difference between an MA and an MS degree, and the acronym only reflects the department or school in which the program is housed. Like doctoral programs, the orientation of master's programs can be more or less practice or research based. Terminal master's programs prepare you for a specific occupation that requires only a master's degree. The nonterminal master's degree is awarded to students as part of their doctoral degree program. If you have any intention of pursuing a doctoral degree after earning an MA, you may not want to apply to a program offering only a terminal master's degree. There are disadvantages as well as advantages to choosing an MA degree over a doctoral degree. The following are some of the advantages. Admission requirements are less stringent for master's applicants than for doctoral applicants. It takes 2-4 years to complete an MA degree as compared to 4-7 years for a doctoral degree. Some master's programs allow part-time study (some PsyD programs also allow part-time study). Most important, a master's degree provides sufficient training and credentials for many areas of employment. There are many career opportunities for individuals with an MA degree, especially in nonclinical areas. The MA degree has several disadvantages as well. For example, career options for someone with an MA degree are limited by state licensing and certification regulations. In the majority of states, individuals with an MA degree cannot obtain a license for independent practice. While you are working on your MA degree, there are several things you can do to increase your chances as a doctoral applicant: Once you have determined your areas of interest and which degree you will pursue, you should seek information on accreditation, licensure, and certification before applying to graduate programs. Accreditation status of a program and licensure may be crucial issues if you are planning to become a practitioner, and may not be relevant at all if you are planning to teach or do research. Getting In (APA, 1993, pp. 54-56) has a brief discussion of these issues. Graduate Study in Psychology, published by APA with yearly updates, provides detailed explanations of accreditation and licensing that you should read. Step 3: Assessing Your Qualifications and Improving Your Chances for AcceptanceAlthough there are many similarities in the admission criteria used by graduate schools, every program is unique and will weigh admission requirements differently. Thus, don't get too discouraged if you are not optimally qualified according to one specific criterion, such as GRE scores. Few students are perfectly qualified according to all of the admission criteria, yet many are accepted in the programs of their choice. Some schools may judge that your strengths in some areas compensate for shortcomings in others. In general, Selection Committees do not evaluate individual criteria in isolation from each other, but rather try to view each applicant's qualifications as a whole.
Nonobjective Criteria Unspecified Criteria
The average minimum overall GPA required by Ph.D. programs is 3.2, and for M.A. programs it is 3.0. Of course, different schools vary in the way they rate GPAs. Some programs will look more closely to the last two years' GPA, and still others will also look at the GPA in psychology courses. Thus, if you have a poor record in your first two years in college, many selection committees will still give you a favorable evaluation if you showed significant improvement in the latter part of your training. In any case, you need to consult individual programs in Graduate Study in Psychology to determine the required and preferred minimums, and to determine whether a program weighs more heavily the overall GPA, psychology GPA, or the last 2-years GPA.
Regular test dates for the GREs are in October, December, February, April, and June, but by paying a higher fee you can take the computerize General GRE (but not the Psychology GRE) any week of the year. In Appendix A (p. 25) you will find information for applying to take the GREs and several references that will help you prepare for the GREs. To take the Psychology GRE or the paper-and-pencil version of the General GRE, you must apply at least 5 weeks in advance of the testing date (4 weeks if you are willing to pay a late registration fee). If you do not meet these deadlines you should call (800) 967-1100 to arrange for computerized testing. Test dates for the MAT vary, depending on the test site. In Appendix A (p. 25) you will find information for applying to take the MAT and several references that will help you prepare for the test. You should actively study for these tests, and you should plan to take them several months before the application deadlines of graduate programs to allow for the possibility of retaking them. What are these tests like? The General GRE consists of three components, each with a multiple-choice format. The Verbal Abilities component (GRE-V) contains analogy, antonym, sentence completion, and reading comprehension questions and exercises. Quantitative Abilities (GRE-Q) tests your ability to perform arithmetic, algebra, geometry, and quantitative comparisons and to interpret data. The GRE-V and GRE-Q are the two components most frequently used by selection committees. The Analytical Abilities component, which is less frequently used, contains analytical reasoning exercises and logic problems. Each component yields a maximum score of 800. The average minimum score required by doctoral programs is 550 for each component, and 1200 for the combined GRE-V + GRE-Q. The required average scores for master's programs are a bit lower. The Psychology GRE consists of about 220 questions drawn from the following subject areas: experimental (e.g., learning, cognition, perception, sensation, ethology, and comparative and physiological psychology); social science (e.g., personality, social, clinical, developmental, and abnormal psychology); and general psychology (e.g., history and systems, applied psychology, tests and measurement, and statistics). The average minimum score required by doctoral programs is also 550 on the Psychology GRE. However, if your score is lower than 550, many schools will still accept your application if your other credentials are superior. The MAT is a 50-minute, 100-items analogy completion test that is quite different from the GREs. Most schools do not require scores on the MAT, but Getting In (APA, 1993) estimates that you would need to score in the range 60-70 correct answers. In any case, you will need to consult Graduate Study in Psychology to determine which standardized test scores are required by the different programs. Preparation for the GRE tests is highly recommended. You should spend 40 to 60 hours preparing for the test. In addition to the references in Appendix A (p. 25) you may choose to take the preparation courses offered by Kaplan's or the Princeton Review. Timing and preparation for the Psychology GRE are somewhat different from the general tests. You should plan to take the Psychology GRE as late as possible and after you have completed most of your psychology courses. In general, you should take the Psychology GRE in October of your senior year. A good textbook in Introductory Psychology, and textbooks in your other courses, will give you the best overview and preparation for the Psychology GRE.
Graduate programs vary a great deal on the required number and type of undergraduate psychology courses taken by the applicant. You should consult Graduate Study in Psychology for the psychology course requirements of different programs. In general, you should have a broad background in undergraduate psychology, such as courses in the areas covered by the Psychology GRE. In addition, take several laboratory-based courses even if you are only planning to apply to professional programs.
You will need three letters of recommendation when applying to most graduate programs. Letters of recommendation are considered to be the most important nonobjective criterion, and sometimes they are given equal weight with GPA and test scores. The best source for recommendation would be your psychology professors who are familiar with your academic ability and are able to comment on your potential as a psychologist. It is crucial that at least one of your letters be written by someone who meets as many of the following criteria: Other sources for recommendation are professors in other disciplines, and professional psychologists or other mental health professionals.
Experience The most common way to obtain research experience is to assist a psychology professor with his or her research. However, assisting professors in other disciplines (e.g., biology, computer science, sociology) is also viewed positively. Designing and conducting your own research through independent study is also considered research experience. Field-related experience is held in high esteem by selection committees. For clinical and counseling programs it would be useful to work or volunteer at mental health settings under the supervision of a psychologist or other mental health professionals. For industrial/organizational programs, experience with personnel issues, training, and organizational change in business, government, or industry is highly valued. In general, you should tailor your field-related experiences to the type of program you want to attend.
Selection committees will be attending not only what you have to say about yourself, but also how you say it. These essays can reveal a great deal about yourself, and your values and priorities. Well-written, articulate essays can be very persuasive, and poorly thought-out and badly written essays can be very damaging. You should ask friends and colleagues, and professors to review your essays.
The interviewer will be interested foremost in assessing how well you seem to fit into the program. The best way to prepare for an interview is to thoroughly acquaint yourself with the program, e.g., its training model, areas of concentration, and philosophy. You should also be familiar with faculty members and their particular areas of interest. In other words, you want to be able to show how your interests and qualifications fit the program. If invited for an interview you should go, even though you will have to incur the expenses. Declining an interview will put you at a disadvantage compared to applicants who made good impressions on their interviews.
Unspecified criteria refer to those criteria that are not directly stated by programs but that can influence your status as an applicant. One such criterion is a resume. Although inclusion of a resume with your application is usually optional, it is recommended for the following reasons: (a) A resume concisely summarizes the most pertinent information about you in an easy- to-read format; (b) people who write letters of recommendation prefer to have them to refer to; (c) most programs will appreciate the fact that you were willing to take this extra step. Another unspecified criterion is the quality of your application materials, which includes neatness, readability, completeness, timeliness, accuracy, and so forth. You should type rather than write on the application forms, and be sure to proofread any materials you submit.
In this section you have learned about the criteria used by Selection Committees to evaluate applicants: objective criteria, nonobjective criteria, and unspecified criteria. You should use this information to assess your qualifications for applying to graduate school. Furthermore, if you plan for graduate school early enough during your undergraduate studies, you may take steps to ensure that you meet the evaluation criteria used by graduate programs, and thus improve your chances for acceptance. Step 4: Choosing Which Programs to Apply ToBefore choosing which programs to apply to, you should fill out the APPLICANT WORKSHEET in Appendix B (p. 27). The Applicant Worksheet will help you organize your thoughts, and it will be a valuable tool for choosing programs, filling out your applications, and preparing for interviews. The Applicant Worksheet is just a prototype, and you should feel free to modify it according to your specific needs. You may wish to consult Getting In (APA, 1993, ch. 5) and Gehlmann et al. (1995) to help you fill out the Applicant Worksheet and other forms in this section. In addition, students planning to apply to programs in Clinical Psychology may wish to consult Walfish et al. (1989).
A good way to begin to compile a preliminary list of programs is to scan the "Index of Programs by Area of Study Offered" in the back of Graduate Study in Psychology and make a mark next to those programs that offer the area of concentration and type of degree you are seeking. To analyze your preliminary list of programs you should fill out the PROGRAM WORKSHEET in Appendix B (p. 30), but first make xerox copies of the Program Worksheet. Your next step will be to estimate the match between the program's admission requirements and your qualifications. Your eventual goal is to identify about 10 programs to which you will apply, with the majority being good matches and some where your qualifications are below the admission requirements (see PROGRAM WORKSHEET). If you are applying to a highly popular area of concentration, such as clinical psychology, you may want to apply to about 12-15 programs, but more than that is not very practical and is not recommended. As of 1993 the minimum cost per application was about $40, so you should try to stay with 10 or so applications. After you have identified the programs you are interested in, write or call them for application forms and general information about the areas of concentration you are considering (addresses can be found in Graduate Study in Psychology). To make a good impression it is important that you prepare your letters requesting information with care, using formal business letter form, typing neatly, and so forth. You should also request information about financial aid from the psychology program and the university financial aid office. While waiting for this information you may wish to consult McWade (1993). You may want to find out about the emotional climate of a program. The best sources for this information are students enrolled in the program, and you should try to contact them, but if this is not feasible you may obtain this information from the American Psychological Association of Graduate Students - (202) 336-6093. Ideally, you should visit every school to which you will apply. Practically, however, many if not most students cannot afford the time nor the money for such visits. Moreover, it is more important to set aside funds to attend preselection interviews requested by many programs, which may have a direct bearing on whether you are accepted by a program.
Step 5: Applying to Graduate ProgramsYou should devise an efficient method for tracking your applications. One suggestion is to use a folder for each application and to use the APPLICATION CHECKLIST in Appendix B (p. 34). You can staple the Application Checklist on the outside of each folder. Remember to make xerox copies of the Application Checklist.You should keep a thorough record of everything you send by making xerox copies of all application materials and correspondence. To make sure that your application has been received you can include a self-addressed, stamped postcard with your application materials; the card should read something to the effect of "This card acknowledges that ___________ (insert name of the university and program) has received a completed application packet." You should type your applications, and have someone else proofread your materials. It is important to be neat and careful since the physical appearance of your materials will influence first impressions. You should double-check every form in the application packet before mailing it. Make xerox copies of the application forms and use them as first drafts. Afterwards you should type the information on the originals. It takes approximately 6 weeks for both transcripts and standardized test scores to be received by the programs, so make sure to submit your request in time. Most programs will send you acknowledgment of receipt. If you have not received confirmation 6 weeks after ordering transcripts and test scores, feel free to call the program to ask if these materials have been received, unless the program instructs you otherwise.
Your resume should not be longer than two pages, and one page is ideal. Headings should emphasize your experiences that are most pertinent to being a psychology student or future psychologist. These might include career objectives, education, papers presented or published, honors, research experience, teaching experience, clinical experience, psychology-related field experience, professional affiliations, and job experience. You might also include general interests, if you think these would contribute to your being viewed as a well-rounded yet professional individual. There are a number of publications, workshops, and computer software to assist you in writing a resume. Any format style is acceptable, as long as the resume is easy to read and the effect is professional.
The most typical themes requested by programs are: (1) your long- term career plans; (2) your area of interest in academic psychology; and (3) your reasons for choosing the program. However, you should follow the instructions in the application materials. Consequently, be prepared to write different essays for the program applications and they should emphasize the match between yourself and a particular program. You should start writing application essays as early as possible. Allow sufficient time to brainstorm, write a first draft, revise it, get feedback, revise again, type it, and proofread it carefully.
Before filling out the forms make xerox copies of them. You will use these copies as first drafts. Afterwards you will type the data or write it legibly in ink on the originals. Many programs require copies of your recent federal tax forms, so make copies of these as soon as possible. Deadlines are for completed applications, and if you omit a single piece of information you may jeopardize your chances for receiving financial aid. Financial aid forms and instructions are typically long and bureaucratic, but it is crucial that you read and heed every instruction and fill in every line.
Step 6: After You Have AppliedIt will take two months or more before you hear from programs to which you have applied. Most decisions for fall enrollment are made between March 1 and April 1. While you are waiting it is suggested that you do three things: (a) prepare yourself for possible rejection; (b) get ready for any interviews you might be invited to attend; and (c) learn how to accept and decline offers appropriately.
Accepting and Declining Offers The proper procedure for accepting or declining offers is to call first, and then write a brief and polite letter. When declining offers, have the courtesy to thank the program for taking the time to consider your application. When you have made your decision, call or write your recommenders to thank them again and let them know which programs accepted you and where you have decided to go. Step 7: Alternatives if You are Not AcceptedBeing rejected by every program you applied to is certainly disappointing, but it does not necessarily mean you should give up your ambition to become a psychologist or to pursue a career in a related field. What should you do now? Basically you have four alternatives: (a) reapply to other programs for the same school year; (b) apply to master's programs if you were rejected by doctoral programs; (c) reapply to the same and other programs for the following school year; or (d) consider alternatives to a graduate degree in psychology.To decide which alternative to pursue, you might first ask yourself whether you set your sights too high and applied to programs with very high admission standards. You can test this by systematically reassessing your qualifications against admission requirements. If, in fact, your credentials were very good, it is possible that the competition this year was exceptionally intense. Sometimes the rejection letters will give you some clues to the reasons for the rejection, and you might feel encouraged to try the same or other programs again, after you have addressed the weaknesses implied in the letters of rejection. It is a good idea to talk to one of your professors to help you with your reassessment.
If your application attempts fail, you may want to consider waiting another year to apply.
To increase your chances of acceptance the second time around, you should try to improve your credentials. This could include taking or retaking courses, retaking tests, and obtaining some solid research or clinical experience.
If you are still interested in pursuing a profession directly related to psychology, there are other graduate degrees that will get you where you want to go. For example, if you are interested in clinical psychology you may consider social work programs with a specialization in mental health or clinical social work. Many education departments also offer degrees in counseling, and marriage and family therapy. If you are interested in organizational psychology you might consider graduate programs in business schools that emphasize organizational development. If you are interested in group behavior you might consider a graduate degree in sociology.
Many of you who worked hard on your applications and who have the potential to become competent psychologists will not be admitted largely because of the limited number of training slots, and that is disheartening. However, those same qualities that may have made you a competent psychologist will serve you well in whichever other path you choose. Keep in mind that psychology is only one house in the community of professions and vocations. |